How Different Pets Can Become the Best of Friends

Published by Kara Murphy
min read

Find food that fits your pet’s needs

Find a dog food that fits your pet’s needs

Find a cat food that fits your pet’s needs

Stories of animals adopting other animals are heartwarming. There are stories like Owen and Mzee, the baby hippo and 130-year-old tortoise or Kasi, the cheetah and Mtani, his canine companion were animals of different species form an unlikely bond. There are also many examples of household pets becoming the best of friends after adoption including orphaned dogs being cared for by an adult cat and vice versa

A Surprising Beginning

Molly and Hope

Nicole Bawol experienced this phenomenon herself when the Humane Society of Northwestern Pennsylvania executive director brought home a month-old foster kitten. The kitten was just a few weeks old when she was found in a parking lot, her leg badly damaged. A veterinarian was forced to amputate the leg and no one knew whether the tiny fluffball would live.

Nicole brought the cat home to care for her post-surgery to give her the best chance of survival. She'd never had a cat in her Erie, Pennsylvania home before and was shocked when her dog, a golden retriever named Molly, was instantly smitten with the tiny kitten.

"We had to keep the kitten in a cage for a while because she was healing from the surgery," Nicole said. "Molly would just lay outside and watch her."

Whenever Nicole took the kitten from the enclosure, Molly wanted to sniff and lick the little cat.

"I was really surprised," Nicole said. "I had no idea she'd react in such a maternal way."

Why Do Animals Adopt Other Animals?

There hasn't been much formal research on animals adopting other animals, but Clive Wynne, a professor of psychology at Arizona State University, told The New York Times that most known interactions take place "in a human-controlled environment."

Marc Bekoff, a professor emeritus of ecology and evolutionary biology at the University of Colorado, Boulder, said he thinks age matters. At least one of the animals involved in interspecies relationships is often a baby when first introduced to his or her companion.

That was certainly the case for the teeny tiny Hope and two-year-old Molly.

An Inseparable, Unlikely Pair

It took about a month for Hope to be well enough to begin roaming the house, learning to totter along on her three legs. Molly would occasionally gently pick up the tiny cat in her mouth—just like a mother dog would do for a puppy—to help her along. The kitten would nap curled up on the big dog's warm back.

Nicole had no intention of keeping the cat. She just planned to foster her until she was well enough to be adopted. But her 10-year-old daughter—who named the cat Hope—convinced Nicole otherwise.

"She said, 'Mommy we're keeping her. You can't take her away because Molly would be so sad,'" Nicole said. "I knew she was right. And that's how Hope came to be part of our family."

Now, the cat and dog sleep together side-by-side at night, and watch the neighborhood together through the glass in the front door during the day. When the mailman approaches Molly barks. The cat hisses. "She thinks she's a dog," Nicole said. "She really does."

Nicole said she believes Hope and Molly are happier because of their bond.

"I'm thrilled to see their relationship," she said. "They're the best of friends."

Is Your House Right for Two Animals?

If you already have a cat or dog and are thinking about adopting an animal of a different species you may wonder if that would really work in your household. It's true that there is a stigma that dogs and cats are the worst of enemies, but that isn't always the case, as Hope and Molly have shown. Each species has its own unique characteristics and their personalities vary from pet to pet, so it's not always easy to tell if everyone will get along well. The easiest way to tell if your dog or cat is ready for a new pet in the house is to understand their current personality. If your dog or cat isn't receptive to change or gets anxiety when loud noises or lots of action happen in your home, they may struggle to take to another pet being in the household. However, if they are very docile and affectionate, listen to you give them a command and do well around other people or animals, they might welcome a new friend into the house.

It is important to Socialise your pets when you first bring home a new companion. Introduce them slowly at first in small supervised interactions and lengthen their encounters over time if they respond well to one another. If you have opportunity to invite a friend or family member over that has a pet of the opposite species of yours, you might be able to gauge how your current pet will react to another fur ball in the house. It is vital that you never force a relationship on either pet. It is important that you really consider both pets before adopting a second one because returning a pet to the shelter is very hard on that pet.

If you decide to adopt a second pet, remember that patience is key. Animals of different species can get along well as long as they are given proper time and space to adjust to the new pet in the home. Over time you might just find out that they can become the best of friends... or at least tolerate each other.

Contributor Bio

Kara Murphy

Kara Murphy

Kara Murphy is a freelance writer in Erie, Pa. She has a goldendoodle named Maddie.

Related Articles

  • Planning a Safe Holiday for Your Dog

    Pet food labels provide basic and limited information on ingredients and nutrient levels. We believe other considerations must be recognized when deciding on which food to feed your pet.
  • Making sense of a pet food label

    Let Hill's help you better understand how to read your pet's food labels, so you can ensure you are purchasing the right product for your dog or cat.
  • How the Loss of a Pet Affects Your Other Pets

    Discover how your pets might be impacted by the loss of another. Learn how to recognize their signs of grieving & how to help them cope with their loss.
  • How to Help a Lost Cat

    Stray Cat Peeking From The Slit Learn tips for what to do if you find a lost cat, including how to determine if it's a feral cat, if it's lost or a stray cat, and how you can help.